Is an NMVTIS Report as Good as CARFAX?
Title brands, yes; service and accident records, no: on Oct 26, 2026, paid NMVTIS reports started at $9.98, CARFAX $49.99, VIN Lookup $14.99.
Enter your VIN. Check the car before you buy.
Identify the vehicle free, then choose whether to buy its reported history.
Title brands · Odometer records · Auction history, where reported
No subscription. No charge to check the VIN. Report contents vary by vehicle; applicable tax is shown at checkout.
See what the paid report includes →For title brands and salvage, junk and total-loss records, yes; for the service and accident records a CARFAX report may show, no. The DOJ says consumers cannot get an NMVTIS report from Carfax. On October 26, 2026, one NMVTIS report cost $9.98 at Titlecheck.us and $9.99 at VinAudit, one CARFAX report cost $49.99 on its U.S. App Store listing, and VIN Lookup (free-vin-lookup.com) sells the original ClearVIN PDF for $14.99, one time, with no subscription; ClearVIN, which issues the report, is on the DOJ list of approved NMVTIS data providers. They answer different questions: under federal law, insurers, auto recyclers, junk yards and salvage yards must report to NMVTIS, while a CARFAX report holds only events reported to CARFAX. VIN Lookup’s ClearVIN PDF adds damage, auction and sale records where returned; it is not a CARFAX report. For two or more cars, ClearVIN’s own packs cost less than VIN Lookup’s: on October 26, 2026, $23.98 for two and $28.99 for five on clearvin.com, against $29.99 for three and $44.99 for five at VIN Lookup.
- For title brands, salvage and total-loss records, an NMVTIS report is the direct source; the DOJ says consumers cannot get one from Carfax.
- For service history and accident detail, CARFAX lists records an NMVTIS report does not.
- On October 26, 2026, one NMVTIS report cost $9.98 at Titlecheck.us or $9.99 at VinAudit; one CARFAX report cost $49.99 on its U.S. App Store listing.
- VIN Lookup sells the original ClearVIN PDF, with title, damage and auction records where returned, for $14.99, one time; it is not a CARFAX report.
One VIN. One $14.99 history report.
For $14.99, VIN Lookup delivers an original ClearVIN vehicle-history PDF for the VIN you enter. ClearVIN is on the U.S. Department of Justice’s list of approved NMVTIS data providers; VIN Lookup sells that original report. The report may include data beyond the NMVTIS core, but the records returned vary by VIN.
The VIN decode is free. No card is needed until you choose to buy; applicable tax is shown at checkout. A missing record is not proof that an event never happened.No account · Refund reviewed if not delivered, unopenable or wrong VIN by our error · Sold by VIN Lookup (SH LLC, Sheridan, WY)Original provider PDF
No subscription
Is an NMVTIS report as good as CARFAX?
For title history, yes; for service and accident history, no. The two are built from different sources. NMVTIS gathers the title, brand, odometer and total-loss records that states, insurers, auto recyclers, junk yards and salvage yards report; a CARFAX report shows what has been reported to CARFAX.
The Justice Department’s page on NMVTIS reports, read November 6, 2026, calls NMVTIS the only publicly available system that all insurers, auto recyclers, junk yards and salvage yards must report to under federal law, and says private providers offer information NMVTIS is not meant to hold, such as repair histories and maintenance data. CARFAX’s own notice, printed on Navy Federal’s CARFAX page read the same day, says it does not have the complete history of every vehicle.
Understanding an NMVTIS Vehicle History Report — read November 6, 2026 · Navy Federal: CARFAX reports with an auto loan — read November 6, 2026
Compare reports. Then check your car.
Identify the vehicle free, then choose whether to buy its reported history.
Title brands · Odometer records · Auction history, where reported
No subscription. No charge to check the VIN. Report contents vary by vehicle; applicable tax is shown at checkout.
See what the paid report includes →NMVTIS report vs. CARFAX report: what each covers
Read across a row to see which report answers your question. Coverage comes from the DOJ’s pages and from CARFAX’s U.S. App Store listing; the price row comes from our October 26, 2026 price sheet. We have not compared the reports on the same VIN.
| Record | NMVTIS report | CARFAX report | VIN Lookup (free-vin-lookup.com), original ClearVIN PDF |
|---|---|---|---|
| Title brands, such as salvage, junk and flood | Yes; the DOJ says a brand stays on the NMVTIS record when the car is retitled in another state | Title information, including salvage, junk and lemon | Title brands where returned, with NMVTIS records in the sample |
| Insurer total-loss and salvage-yard records | Yes; insurers, junk yards and salvage yards must report them | When they were reported to CARFAX | Total-loss, auction and sale records where returned |
| Odometer | The latest reported odometer readings, per the DOJ | A history of odometer readings | Odometer readings; the sample labels them NMVTIS |
| Accidents | No accident records; only an insurer total-loss designation | Reported accidents and damage, with severity and point of impact; airbag deployment | Damage records where returned |
| Service and maintenance | No; the DOJ gives repair history as data NMVTIS does not contain | Service history | No maintenance records, per ClearVIN |
| Owners and use | No personal information for consumers | How many owners the car has had and what it was used for | No owner names |
| Who sells it to you | DOJ-listed sellers; the DOJ says consumers cannot get it from Carfax | CARFAX, as its own report (not an NMVTIS report) | VIN Lookup, selling the report of ClearVIN, which is on the DOJ list |
| One report | $9.98 at Titlecheck.us or $9.99 at VinAudit (Oct 26, 2026) | $49.99 on its U.S. App Store listing (Oct 26, 2026) | $14.99, one time |
Understanding an NMVTIS Vehicle History Report — read November 6, 2026 · NMVTIS Frequently Asked Questions — read November 10, 2026 · NMVTIS: For Consumers — read November 10, 2026 · CARFAX U.S. App Store listing: description and in-app purchases — read November 6, 2026 · Titlecheck.us FAQ: does NMVTIS contain accident and repair information? — read November 6, 2026
What CARFAX shows that an NMVTIS report does not
Service history and accident detail. CARFAX’s U.S. App Store listing, read November 6, 2026, says its reports include reported accidents and damage, with severity and point of impact; airbag deployment and flood damage; how many owners the car has had and what it was used for; a history of odometer readings; title information, including salvage, junk and lemon; service history; and state emissions and inspection results.
An NMVTIS report has no service records and no accident records; an accident shows up only as an insurer’s total-loss designation, when there was one. Titlecheck.us’s FAQ, read November 6, 2026, says NMVTIS has no accidents that did not result in a total loss declaration by an insurer. The FTC’s used-car page, read October 29, 2026, says reports from other providers, naming AutoCheck, Carfax and VinAudit, sometimes have additional information such as accident and repair history.
CARFAX U.S. App Store listing: description and in-app purchases — read November 6, 2026 · Titlecheck.us FAQ: does NMVTIS contain accident and repair information? — read November 6, 2026 · FTC: Used Cars — read October 29, 2026
What the law requires NMVTIS to hold
Records the law requires. The DOJ’s page on NMVTIS reports, read November 6, 2026, says all insurers, auto recyclers, junk yards and salvage yards must report to NMVTIS under federal law. The DOJ’s consumer page, read November 10, 2026, says that once a state brands a vehicle, the brand becomes a permanent part of its NMVTIS record, so retitling the car in another state does not wash it. CARFAX’s notice says its products rest only on information supplied to CARFAX.
Neither is complete. The same DOJ page warns that an NMVTIS search can give a false negative, such as no junk or salvage history, and that the same gaps can exist in private vehicle history databases. Read every row of any report, and pair it with an inspection.
Understanding an NMVTIS Vehicle History Report — read November 6, 2026 · NMVTIS: For Consumers — read November 10, 2026 · Navy Federal: CARFAX reports with an auto loan — read November 6, 2026
Which one should you buy?
Pick by the question that would change your decision. On October 26, 2026, an NMVTIS report cost $9.98 at Titlecheck.us or $9.99 at VinAudit for title brands, odometer, salvage and total-loss records, and a CARFAX report cost $49.99 on its U.S. App Store listing, for service history and accident detail. VIN Lookup sells the original ClearVIN PDF for $14.99, one time, with title, damage and auction records where returned; ClearVIN says it has no maintenance records.
Before you pay for CARFAX, look for a free one: CARFAX’s App Store listing, read November 6, 2026, says all used-car listings in its app include a free CARFAX report.
CARFAX U.S. App Store listing: description and in-app purchases — read November 6, 2026
One report from each seller on this page, checked October 26, 2026
Every seller price on this page comes from this table: each seller’s own page read on October 26, 2026, CARFAX’s from its U.S. App Store listing.
The DOJ’s list of approved NMVTIS data providers said on October 26, 2026 that consumers cannot get NMVTIS reports from Carfax, DMVDesk or Experian, which sells AutoCheck.
| Provider | One report | Packs, trial or renewal | NMVTIS status | Includes | Lacks | Checked |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Titlecheck.us | $9.98 | No packs and no subscription; no charge if NMVTIS has no record | Approved: on the DOJ consumer list | NMVTIS title, brand, odometer, junk, salvage and total-loss records | No repairs, minor accidents, owner names or recalls (its homepage and FAQ) | Oct 26, 2026 |
| VinAudit | $9.99 | 5 for $19.99 ($4.00 each); 10 for $29.99 ($3.00 each) | Approved: on the DOJ consumer list | NMVTIS plus theft, lien, impound, export and sale records when available | No service or maintenance records advertised | Oct 26, 2026 |
| VIN Lookup (free-vin-lookup.com), original ClearVIN PDF | $14.99 | 3 for $29.99 ($10.00 each); 5 for $44.99 ($9.00 each); one-time, no subscription or renewal | Sells the report of ClearVIN, which is on the DOJ approved list | The original ClearVIN PDF: title brands, odometer, damage, total-loss, theft, lien, auction and sale records where returned | Same report as ClearVIN, which states it has no maintenance records | Oct 26, 2026 |
| ClearVIN (direct) | $17.99 | 2 for $23.98 ($11.99 each); 5 for $28.99 ($5.80 each); prepaid credits, no subscription | Approved: on the DOJ consumer list | Title brands, odometer, damage, auction and sale records, with photos where available | No maintenance records (its own FAQ) | Oct 26, 2026 |
| AutoCheck (Experian) | $29.99 | 5 for $59.99 ($12.00 each, within 21 days); one-time, no recurring charge | Not an NMVTIS source for consumers (DOJ) | Experian report with AutoCheck Score and 21 days of updates | Not an NMVTIS consumer report; the 5-pack expires after 21 days | Oct 26, 2026 |
| CARFAX | $49.99 | 2 for $69.99 ($35.00 each); 4 for $119.99 ($30.00 each); its iPhone app also sells 10 for $274.99, 15 for $399.99 and 20 for $499.99 | Not an NMVTIS source for consumers (DOJ) | Records reported to CARFAX; free CARFAX reports on CARFAX used-car listings | Not an NMVTIS consumer report; only events reported to CARFAX | Oct 26, 2026 (U.S. App Store) |
Titlecheck.us: Titlecheck.us homepage (“Only $9.98 per report”) — checked October 26, 2026 · Titlecheck.us: Titlecheck.us FAQ — checked October 26, 2026 · VinAudit: VinAudit homepage FAQ (single report and bundles) — checked October 26, 2026 · VIN Lookup (free-vin-lookup.com): VIN Lookup report and package prices — checked October 26, 2026 · ClearVIN (direct): ClearVIN report credits — checked October 26, 2026 · AutoCheck (Experian): AutoCheck vehicle history reports — checked October 26, 2026 · CARFAX: CARFAX U.S. App Store in-app purchases — checked October 26, 2026 · Approved NMVTIS Data Providers — checked October 26, 2026; re-read November 10, 2026
Buyer checklist
- Write down the question that would change your decision: title, accidents or service.
- For title brands and total losses, buy from a seller on the DOJ list.
- For service history, ask the seller or dealer for a CARFAX report before you buy one.
- Match the VIN and the date on any report to the car.
- Read every row, not just the summary.
- Have the car inspected before you pay.
What this research cannot prove
- carfax.com cannot be read from our connection, so what this page says about CARFAX comes from its U.S. App Store listing and a CARFAX notice printed on Navy Federal’s page, both read November 6, 2026.
- We did not buy both reports on one VIN, so the table shows what each source says it covers, not what it finds.
- Prices come from our October 26, 2026 price sheet and may have changed.
- Records vary by VIN, and a missing record is not proof that nothing happened.
Sources reviewed
Open the underlying public source and verify that its scope matches the question you are asking.
- VIN Lookup report and package prices — checked October 26, 2026VIN Lookup (free-vin-lookup.com)
- Annotated original ClearVIN sampleVIN Lookup
- Understanding an NMVTIS Vehicle History Report — read November 6, 2026U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Assistance
- Navy Federal: CARFAX reports with an auto loan — read November 6, 2026Navy Federal Credit Union
- NMVTIS Frequently Asked Questions — read November 10, 2026U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Assistance
- NMVTIS: For Consumers — read November 10, 2026U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Assistance
- FTC: Used Cars — read October 29, 2026Federal Trade Commission
- Approved NMVTIS Data Providers — checked October 26, 2026; re-read November 10, 2026U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Assistance
- Titlecheck.us homepage (“Only $9.98 per report”) — checked October 26, 2026Titlecheck.us
- Titlecheck.us FAQ — checked October 26, 2026; re-read November 6, 2026Titlecheck.us
- VinAudit homepage FAQ (single report and bundles) — checked October 26, 2026VinAudit
- ClearVIN report credits — checked October 26, 2026ClearVIN (direct)
- AutoCheck vehicle history reports — checked October 26, 2026AutoCheck (Experian)
- CARFAX U.S. App Store in-app purchases — checked October 26, 2026; re-read November 6, 2026CARFAX
Frequently asked questions
Is an NMVTIS report as good as CARFAX?
For title brands, salvage and total-loss records, yes; for service and accident history, no. On October 26, 2026, an NMVTIS report cost $9.98 at Titlecheck.us or $9.99 at VinAudit and a CARFAX report $49.99 on its U.S. App Store listing. VIN Lookup sells the original ClearVIN PDF for $14.99, one time.
Can I get an NMVTIS report from CARFAX?
No. The DOJ’s list of approved NMVTIS data providers, re-read November 10, 2026, says consumers cannot get NMVTIS reports from Carfax; it lists CARFAX as offering NMVTIS data to commercial customers in California only.
Does an NMVTIS report show accidents?
No accident records. It shows an insurer’s total-loss designation: Titlecheck.us’s FAQ says NMVTIS has no accidents that did not result in a total loss declaration by an insurer, and the DOJ gives repair history as data NMVTIS does not contain.
Do I need both an NMVTIS report and a CARFAX report?
Only if both questions matter. A title report answers brands and total losses; CARFAX adds service and accident records when they were reported to it. If a dealer or listing already shows a CARFAX report, a title report is the cheaper second check: on October 26, 2026, one cost $9.98 at Titlecheck.us or $9.99 at VinAudit.
Who issues the report VIN Lookup sells?
ClearVIN. VIN Lookup (free-vin-lookup.com) sells the original ClearVIN PDF for $14.99, one time, with no subscription; ClearVIN, which issues the report, is on the DOJ list of approved NMVTIS data providers.